What Israel’s Place in God’s Plan Means for the Church Today
Part 4 of 4: Living With Two Peoples
Hello brothers and sisters.
This is the finale of a 4-part series exploring replacement theology (supersessionism), its historical roots, its biblical problems, and why it matters for every Christian.
In Part 1, we examined the real-world consequences of this theology and introduced the core problem: if God broke His covenant with Israel, no promise He’s ever made is secure.
In Part 2, we traced how replacement theology developed through history; not from careful exegesis, but from cultural pressure, political convenience, and philosophical assumptions that the early church fathers never derived from careful study of Scripture.
In Part 3, we turned to Scripture itself and found that the biblical case against replacement theology is overwhelming: unconditional covenants that depend on God’s character, proof texts that crumble under contextual scrutiny, Paul’s sustained argument in Romans 9–11, and prophetic promises so explicit that only allegory can evade them.
If you haven’t read Parts 1-3, I’d encourage you to start there.
How Did We Get Here? The Historical Development of Replacement Theology
The Biblical Case Against Replacement Theology
Now we come to the question that matters most:
So what? If God hasn’t replaced Israel, what does that mean for how we live, how we think, and how we relate to the Jewish people?
Let’s dig in.
If you’re reading this in email, be aware that the text is likely to cut off without warning. For a smoother reading experience and all the features Substack has to offer (including audio voiceovers of my posts), you can go HERE or download the app.
The Question Everyone Is Really Asking
If you’ve stayed with me through this entire series, I suspect you’ve had a question forming in the back of your mind. Maybe you’ve been too polite to ask it. Maybe you’re not sure how to frame it. But I think it goes something like this:
Okay, Kevin. Let’s say you’re right. God hasn’t replaced Israel. The covenants are still in force. Paul said what Paul said. But what am I supposed to do with that?
Fair question. Let’s talk about it.
Because the truth is, if this is just an academic exercise— if we can prove replacement theology is wrong but it changes nothing about how we live our faith —then what was the point? I didn’t write 25,000 words across four posts just to win an argument. I wrote them because I believe getting this right changes how we understand God, how we read Scripture, how we relate to Jewish people, and how we live as followers of Jesus (or as our Messianic Jewish brothers and sisters say, Yeshua).
The Two Errors: Replacement and Separation
Before we go any further, I need to address something that some readers may not expect. Because there are actually two errors on the table, and they’re mirror images of each other.
The first error is the one we’ve spent three posts dismantling: replacement theology, the belief that God is finished with Israel and the Church has taken her place.
The second error is less discussed in evangelical circles, but just as dangerous: dual covenant theology, the belief that Jewish people don’t need Jesus (Yeshua) because they already have their own covenant with God that provides its own path to salvation.
This view shows up in various forms. Sometimes it’s explicit, as in the writings of certain liberal theologians who argue that Christianity is for Gentiles and Judaism is for Jews, and that each tradition offers a valid path to God. More often, it’s implicit; a vague discomfort with the idea that Jewish people need the gospel, or a feeling that evangelism toward Jews is somehow disrespectful or even antisemitic.
I understand the impulse. After two thousand years of Christian persecution of Jewish people— the very history we traced in Part 2 —it makes sense that many Christians would feel uneasy about approaching Jews with the gospel. “Haven’t we done enough damage?” they think. “Can’t we just leave them alone?”
But here’s the problem: dual covenant theology, however well-intentioned, makes the same mistake as replacement theology. Replacement theology says God is done with Israel’s unique role. Dual covenant theology says Israel doesn’t need Israel’s own Messiah.
Both positions deny what Scripture teaches.
Paul— himself an Israelite, a Pharisee of Pharisees, a man who would have traded his own salvation for his kinsmen (Romans 9:3) —was unambiguous:
“Brothers and sisters, my heart’s desire and prayer to God for them is that they may be saved.” (Romans 10:1, NRSV)
Paul is praying for Israel’s salvation. Not their cultural preservation. Not their political flourishing. Their salvation. Through Yeshua, the Messiah whom Paul spent his life proclaiming to Jew and Gentile alike.
If the Abrahamic covenant alone were sufficient for salvation, Paul’s prayer makes no sense. If Jewish people don’t need Yeshua, Paul wasted his life.
Jesus Himself said: “I am the way, and the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me” (John 14:6, NRSV). No one. This isn’t referring to Gentiles only. Nor is it “Gentiles plus Jews who are especially sinful.” No one. Absolutely no one comes to the father except through Jesus. The scope is universal because the need is universal.
And let me push this further, because I think this point is too important to state once and move on. The entire sacrificial system of the Old Testament— every lamb slaughtered at Passover, every bull offered on the Day of Atonement, every burnt offering on the bronze altar —was a shadow, a type, a pointer. The author of Hebrews tells us these sacrifices could never actually take away sin (Hebrews 10:4). They were object lessons. They taught Israel what atonement required— the shedding of innocent blood —without providing the reality.
The reality was always Yeshua.
This means that even under the old covenant, it was never the sacrificial system itself that saved. It was the faith that the system pointed toward. Abraham “believed the Lord, and he reckoned it to him as righteousness” (Genesis 15:6, NRSV). David found forgiveness not through animal blood but through genuine repentance and trust in God’s mercy (Psalm 51). The prophets consistently taught that God desired obedience over sacrifice, mercy over ritual (Hosea 6:6, Micah 6:6–8).
The Messiah is not a detour from Israel’s story. He is its destination. And suggesting that Jewish people can reach that destination without the One who claimed to be the destination is not respect for Judaism. It’s a denial of what Judaism’s own Scriptures teach.
So the correct position is not replacement (God is done with Israel) or separation (Israel doesn’t need the Messiah). It’s what we might call completion: Israel’s covenants are fulfilled— not abolished —in Yeshua. The Messiah doesn’t cancel Israel’s story. He is the climax of it. He is the Seed of Abraham, the Son of David, the Prophet like Moses, the Suffering Servant of Isaiah, the Anointed One of Daniel’s vision. Everything Israel was promised finds its “yes” in Him (2 Corinthians 1:20).
Jewish people need Yeshua. Not because their covenants are broken, but because their covenants point to Him.
Israel Needs Her Messiah: The Messianic Jewish Community
This brings us to one of the most remarkable— and overlooked —movements in modern Christianity: Messianic Judaism.
Messianic Jews are Jewish people who believe that Yeshua (Jesus) is the promised Messiah of Israel. They maintain their Jewish identity, observe Jewish traditions and festivals, and worship in ways that reflect their heritage. They are not “converts to Christianity” in the way that term is usually understood. They are Jews who have found their Messiah, the One their own Scriptures promised.
But allow me let Messianic Jews define themselves, because they do it far better than I can.
As Diane Ferreira, founder of the Substack publication “She’s So Scripture” (and for the record, if you don’t read her publication yet, you should fix that!) and herself a Messianic Jew, explains:
“Messianic Judaism is rooted in the early Jewish followers of Yeshua who lived in the first century. These earliest believers, known as “The Way” (HaDerekh), were Jewish men and women who accepted Yeshua as the Messiah while continuing to live observant Jewish lives. The Book of Acts records that the apostles and other Jewish believers— including Yeshua’s own family —remained deeply connected to the Torah and the Temple, participating in Jewish religious life and observing Jewish laws (Acts 21:20). What we now call Messianic Judaism, then, is not a modern invention. It is the re-emergence of one of the oldest forms of Jewish faith.”
The Union of Messianic Jewish Congregations (UMJC) defines the movement as:
“a movement of Jewish congregations and groups committed to Yeshua the Messiah that embrace the covenantal responsibility of Jewish life and identity rooted in Torah, expressed in tradition, and renewed and applied in the context of the New Covenant.”
Rabbi Paul Saal of Congregation Shuvah Yisrael puts it beautifully:
“Like all other forms of Judaism, we seek to live in ways that resonate with our Jewish past and present. But our Messiah takes center-stage as we seek to live as faithful Jews. The centrality of Messiah Yeshua puts us in profound spiritual unity with people in another worldwide community—the Christian Church. Though we practice our faith differently, we have deep appreciation for the Church. Our primary sense of identity lies with the Jewish people. But, we share a deep bond with all who see Jesus as the ultimate answer to the great questions of life.”
This is a critical point. Messianic Jews do not see their faith in Yeshua as a break from Judaism, but as its fulfillment. As Ferreira writes, they remain connected to both their Jewish heritage and community. For Messianic Jews, Yeshua’s coming does not abolish the Torah but rather fulfills it exactly as Yeshua Himself said: “Do not think that I came to abolish the Torah or the Prophets! I did not come to abolish, but to fulfill” (Matthew 5:17).
As scholar David Rudolph notes:
“In the late 1960’s and early 1970’s, a large number of Jews in their twenties became believers in Yeshua and refused to assimilate into Gentile churches. They wanted to maintain their Jewish identity and live as Jews.”
This impulse— to follow Yeshua without ceasing to be Jewish —is the heartbeat of the movement.
And Messianic Jews are emphatic on the point that matters most for our series: they vehemently reject Replacement Theology. They believe that God’s covenant with Israel is everlasting and that Jewish believers in Yeshua are part of the larger Jewish community, not defectors from it.
It’s also worth noting that many Messianic congregations welcome non-Jewish members who feel called to participate in Jewish communal life. These “Messianic Gentiles,” are not Jews and do not claim to be. They are Gentile believers who, under the covering of a Messianic synagogue and the leadership of a rabbi, choose to worship within a Jewish framework and participate in the life and destiny of the Jewish people.
Think of Ruth the Moabitess (grandmother of King David). She never stopped being a Moabitess, but she committed her life to the God of Israel and the people of Israel. The God-fearers in Acts, like Cornelius, offer another precedent.
This is distinct from what’s known as the “Hebrew Roots” movement, which tends to involve Gentile Christians adopting Jewish practices outside of Jewish communal life and rabbinic leadership. Unfortunately, practitioners of this movement sometimes unknowingly appropriate Jewish culture without its proper context.
Another precedent for this comes from Isaiah 56:4-7:
For thus says the Lord:
To the eunuchs who keep my Sabbaths, who choose the things that please me and hold fast my covenant, I will give, in my house and within my walls, a monument and a name better than sons and daughters; I will give them an everlasting name that shall not be cut off.
And the foreigners who join themselves to the Lord, to minister to him, to love the name of the Lord, and to be his servants, all who keep the Sabbath and do not profane it and hold fast my covenant—these I will bring to my holy mountain and make them joyful in my house of prayer; their burnt offerings and their sacrifices will be accepted on my altar, for my house shall be called a house of prayer for all peoples.
Now read that last part again. “a house of prayer for ALL peoples.” It’s a powerful statement both for Christians and for Messianic Gentiles.
But to return us to the point at hand (the Messianic Jewish movement), one fact needs to be born in mind when we really look at the history of the movement. Which is that their growth is nothing short of astonishing.
In 1948, when the modern state of Israel was established, there were an estimated 23 Jewish believers in Yeshua in the entire country. Twenty-three. Out of 600,000 Jewish residents. There were no Messianic congregations. Not one.
By 1967— the year of the Six-Day War, when Jerusalem was reunited under Israeli sovereignty —something began to shift. The Jesus Movement that swept across America in the late 1960s brought thousands of young Jewish believers to faith, many of whom eventually immigrated to Israel. Organizations like Jews for Jesus (founded in 1973) gave the movement visibility and structure.
By 1989, Israel’s Jewish population had grown to 3.5 million, and the estimated number of believers had reached 1,200 with 30 congregations. By 1999, there were approximately 5,000 believers worshipping in 81 Messianic congregations. By 2017, that number had tripled to over 300 congregations.
Today, conservative estimates place the number of Messianic Jews in Israel at roughly 30,000. Worldwide, estimates range from around one hundred thousand to as many as 1.5 million, depending on how broadly you define the community (some congregations include significant numbers of Gentile members who worship alongside their Jewish brothers and sisters).
Let me put this in perspective. In 1948: 23 believers. In 2025: 30,000 in Israel alone, potentially over a million worldwide. That’s not gradual growth. That’s exponential. And it’s happened in the face of significant opposition; from anti-missionary organizations like Yad L’Achim, from cultural pressure, from the fact that Israeli society often views Messianic Jews as traitors to their heritage.
And yet they keep growing. Something is happening. Something that looks, to my eyes, a lot like the beginning of what Paul described in Romans 11.
Here’s where I want to share something that falls squarely into the category of “interesting observation, but not doctrine.” There’s a view held by some that the 144,000 sealed servants of God in Revelation 7— described explicitly as coming from the twelve tribes of Israel —represent a community of Messianic Jewish believers who will play a unique role in the end times. Some conservative estimates of the current global Messianic Jewish population land surprisingly close to that number.
I want to be very clear: I am not building doctrine on a population estimate. Numbers change. Definitions vary. And Revelation’s symbolism doesn’t lend itself to that kind of mathematical precision. But I’d be lying if I said I hadn’t noticed, and I find it at least worth pondering. The text of Revelation is clear that the 144,000 are “from every tribe of the sons of Israel” (Revelation 7:4, NRSV). These are Jewish believers, sealed and set apart for God’s purposes. Whether the number is symbolic of completeness or literal, the theological point remains: God has a plan for Jewish believers in the last days, and the Messianic Jewish community may well be the firstfruits of that plan.
How Should We Approach Our Jewish Neighbors?
If Israel needs her Messiah, what does that mean for how we— Gentile Christians —relate to Jewish people?
First, let me say what it does not mean. It does not mean confrontational evangelism. It does not mean treating Jewish people as “targets” or “projects.” It does not mean approaching them with the assumption that we understand their own Scriptures better than they do. And it absolutely does not mean ignoring two millennia of Christian antisemitism and pretending we’re starting from a clean slate. We’re not. The history we traced in Part 2 is real, and Jewish people remember it even when we don’t.
What it does mean is this: sharing the good news of Yeshua with Jewish people is the most loving thing we can do. Not “converting Jews to Christianity,” as that framing misunderstands the entire point. We’re inviting our Jewish brothers and sisters to discover their own Messiah. To come home, as it were, to the fulfillment of promises God made to their ancestors millennia ago.
A Jewish person who comes to faith in Yeshua doesn’t stop being Jewish. They become more Jewish, not less. They will continue to observe the biblical Sabbath, celebrate the feasts, study Torah, and honor their heritage. And do it all in the light of the Messiah to whom every feast, every sacrifice, every promise pointed.
This is a crucial distinction, and I want to make sure it’s clear. When I talk about sharing the gospel with Jewish people, I’m not talking about “converting Jews to Christianity” in the way that phrase has historically been understood. For most of Christian history, Jewish converts were expected to abandon everything Jewish about themselves. From their Sabbath to their dietary laws, their festivals, and their cultural identity. They were expected to become, essentially, Gentiles.
That’s not what I’m advocating. At all.
What I’m talking about is inviting Jewish people to consider their own Messiah. The One their own prophets foretold. The One their own Scriptures describe. The One who was born Jewish, lived Jewish, died Jewish, and rose again as the promised King of Israel.
A Jew who comes to faith in Yeshua isn’t leaving Judaism. They’re entering more deeply into its fulfillment. They’re finding the destination that every Passover lamb, every Day of Atonement sacrifice, every prophetic promise was pointing toward.
This is what the Messianic Jewish community embodies. And one of the most practical things we can do is support that community, whether it be financially, prayerfully, or relationally. When we help a Messianic congregation thrive, we’re not building a bridge between two different religions. We’re helping to restore a reality that existed from the very beginning: Jews who follow their Messiah while remaining unapologetically Jewish.
I’m not saying you need to go knock on doors in a Jewish neighborhood. What I am saying is that if God brings a Jewish person into your life, you should be ready— gently, humbly, with full awareness of the historical baggage —to share what you believe and why. Not with a sledgehammer. With love. With respect. With the understanding that you are a wild olive branch speaking to someone whose roots run deeper than yours.
Paul modeled this. He went to the synagogues first, every time. He reasoned from their own Scriptures. He loved his people even when they rejected him. He never stopped believing that Israel would be saved. And he asked Gentile believers to pray for that very thing (Romans 10:1).
We should do the same.
Thinking Prophetically About Modern Israel
Now let’s address the elephant in the room that every discussion of Israel eventually encounters: the modern State of Israel.
I believe the establishment of Israel in 1948 is prophetically significant. I said it in Part 3, and I’ll say it again here: when you read Ezekiel 37— the valley of dry bones, the promise that God would bring His people back to the land of Israel —and then you watch a nation reborn after nearly two thousand years of exile, you are watching prophecy unfold in real time.
No other nation in history has been scattered across the globe for two millennia and then reconstituted in its ancestral homeland. None. The very existence of modern Israel is, to my mind, one of the most powerful evidences of biblical prophecy that we have.
But— and this is important —prophetic significance does not equal unconditional political endorsement.
Let me be direct. I believe Israel had every right to defend itself after the attack from Gaza in October 2023. That attack was horrific, unprovoked terrorism that targeted civilians, including women, children, and the elderly. No nation on earth would be expected to absorb such an attack without response.
But I also believe that in its response, Israel has crossed lines that should concern every person of conscience, regardless of their theology. The scale of civilian casualties in Gaza, the displacement of hundreds of thousands of people, the destruction of infrastructure… these are not things I can wave away with a “but prophecy” shrug.
You can believe that God is fulfilling His promises through Israel’s existence and simultaneously hold Israel’s government accountable for its decisions. These are not contradictory positions. They’re the only intellectually honest ones.
Think about it this way. In the Old Testament, when Israel sinned, God didn’t revoke His covenant. We’ve established that thoroughly. But He also didn’t ignore the sin. He sent prophets. He allowed consequences. He disciplined His people precisely because they were His people. “You only have I known of all the families of the earth; therefore I will punish you for all your iniquities,” God said through Amos (Amos 3:2, NRSV).
Being chosen doesn’t mean being above critique. It means being held to a higher standard. The prophets understood this. We should too.
So when I say I believe in Israel’s prophetic significance, I don’t mean “Israel can do no wrong.” I mean that God is not finished with this nation, that He is working out His purposes through its existence, and that its restoration to the land is a sign that the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob keeps His promises across millennia.
What Israel’s government does with that restored land is subject to the same moral scrutiny we’d apply to any nation. Christians who think supporting Israel means defending every military action, every policy, every political decision are making a serious error. And Christians who think criticizing Israel’s policies means denying its prophetic significance are making a different error.
I’ve encountered both extremes. I’ve met Christians who treat any criticism of Israel as tantamount to opposing God. I’ve met others who use Israel’s imperfections as evidence that it can’t possibly be the fulfillment of biblical prophecy. Both miss the point entirely.
God’s promises to Israel were made to a sinful people. That was always the case. Abraham lied about Sarah being his wife. Jacob deceived his father. Moses struck the rock in anger. David committed adultery and murder. Solomon fell into idolatry. The entire history of the kingdoms of Israel and Judah is a story of unfaithfulness met by divine patience.
If God only kept His promises to perfect people, He’d have no one to keep them to.
Modern Israel is a nation of imperfect people making imperfect decisions in an impossibly complex geopolitical situation. That is entirely consistent with the Israel of the Bible. And it is entirely consistent with a God who works through flawed vessels to accomplish His purposes.
So support Israel’s right to exist. Pray for her people. Acknowledge the miraculous nature of her restoration. And hold her government accountable with the same moral standards you’d apply to any other nation on earth. That’s not contradiction. That’s integrity.
The truth, as usual, is more nuanced than either extreme.
The Eschatological Framework: Israel’s Eyes Will Be Opened
I’ve hinted at this throughout the series, but now let me lay it out more directly. Because the prophetic trajectory of Israel isn’t just about the past (covenants made) or the present (a nation restored). It’s about the future.
Paul tells us something extraordinary in Romans 11:
“A hardening has come upon part of Israel, until the full number of the Gentiles has come in. And so all Israel will be saved.” (Romans 11:25–26a, NRSV)
We discussed this passage in detail in Part 3. But I want to draw out its implications for how we think about the future.
Israel’s current spiritual condition— a majority that does not recognize Yeshua as Messiah —is not permanent. Paul describes it as a “hardening” that has come upon “part” of Israel. Not all. Part. And it has a timeline: it lasts “until the full number of the Gentiles has come in.”
That word “until” (ἄχρι οὗ, achri hou) is crucial. It means there is an expiration date on Israel’s hardening. When God’s purposes for the nations are complete, the veil over Israel’s eyes will be lifted.
And then? “All Israel will be saved.” The Deliverer will come from Zion. He will banish ungodliness from Jacob. God will take away their sins (Romans 11:26–27).
This is not replacement. This is restoration.
Zechariah paints the same picture from the prophetic side:
“And I will pour out a spirit of compassion and supplication on the house of David and the inhabitants of Jerusalem, so that, when they look on the one whom they have pierced, they shall mourn for him, as one mourns for an only child, and weep bitterly over him, as one weeps over a firstborn.” (Zechariah 12:10, NRSV)
This is Israel recognizing her Messiah. Looking upon the One they pierced— Yeshua —and mourning. Not with the mourning of despair, but with the mourning of recognition. The kind of grief that comes when you finally see what you’ve been missing. An entire nation, simultaneously realizing that the One they’ve rejected for two thousand years was, all along, exactly who He said He was.
The Hebrew here is staggering. The word for “pierced” is דָּקָרוּ (daqaru),the same verb used for thrusting a sword or spear through someone. This is the piercing of the cross. And the mourning described, compared to the loss of a firstborn son, is the most devastating loss in ancient culture. Israel’s recognition of Yeshua will not be a casual “oh, we were wrong.” It will be a national reckoning of the most profound kind.
And Revelation brings this full circle. Jesus says in Revelation 1:7: “Look! He is coming with the clouds; every eye will see him, even those who pierced him” (NRSV). The connection to Zechariah is unmistakable. John is telling us that Zechariah’s prophecy— Israel looking on the One they pierced —will be fulfilled at the second coming of Christ.
But here’s the detail that connects this to the specific sequence of events. Jesus Himself, in Matthew 23:37–39, makes a statement that often gets overlooked in discussions about Israel’s future:
“Jerusalem, Jerusalem, the city that kills the prophets and stones those who are sent to it! How often have I desired to gather your children together as a hen gathers her brood under her wings, and you were not willing! See, your house is left to you, desolate. For I tell you, you will not see me again until you say, ‘Blessed is the one who comes in the name of the Lord.’” (Matthew 23:37–39, NRSV)
Read that last sentence carefully. Jesus says Israel will not see Him again until they say, “Blessed is the one who comes in the name of the Lord.” This is a quotation of Psalm 118:26, which is a messianic acclamation. Jesus is saying that His return is contingent upon Israel’s national recognition of Him as Messiah.
This isn’t a condition God arbitrarily imposed. It’s the fulfillment of the pattern. Just as Israel’s leaders led the nation to reject the Messiah at His first coming, Israel will eventually— led by whatever remnant exists at that time —petition Him to return. The rejection that happened corporately must be reversed corporately.
This is why the Messianic Jewish movement matters so much. Every Jewish person who comes to faith in Yeshua is a step toward that day. Every Messianic congregation is evidence that the hardening is partial, not total. It also shows that God is actively at work preparing His people for the moment when the veil is lifted.
Now, as I’ve talked about before, I lean toward a futurist eschatology. I believe the 70th week of Daniel is still future, and that there will be a period of tribulation that precedes Christ’s return (we explored this in my deep dive post where we explored the 70 weeks of Daniel 9). I believe the Church Age represents the gap between Daniel’s 69th and 70th weeks, and that God’s prophetic clock for Israel will resume when the full number of the Gentiles has come in.
But I recognize that godly, intelligent scholars hold different eschatological frameworks. Some see these prophecies as having been fulfilled in the first century. Some hold an amillennial or postmillennial view that interprets these passages differently.
Here’s what I think we can all agree on, regardless of our eschatological framework: God is not finished with Israel. Whether you see Israel’s ultimate restoration as future-literal, present-spiritual, or some combination of both, the biblical testimony is clear that Israel retains a unique place in God’s purposes. Paul said it. The prophets said it. Jesus Himself said it.
And the growth of the Messianic Jewish movement— from 23 believers in Israel in 1948 to tens of thousands today —suggests that whatever God is doing, He’s already begun.
Practical Steps: How to Respond
Before I offer specific suggestions, I want to acknowledge something that I think needs saying. After tracing the history in Part 2— from what Chrysostom said about Jewish people to what Luther proposed, to what centuries of Christian theology made possible —I do think the Church owes Israel something.
Not guilt as a permanent state. Not self-flagellation. But honest acknowledgment and deliberate correction.
We got this wrong. For a very long time, the Church taught things about the Jewish people that were not only theologically incorrect but morally devastating. The fact that most modern Christians who hold supersessionist views would never dream of persecuting Jewish people doesn’t erase the historical record. The theology that enabled that persecution is the same theology we’ve been critiquing in this series.
So when I offer these practical suggestions, I’m not offering them as “nice things to do.” I’m offering them as corrections. Ways to live out the truth that God has not abandoned His people, and neither should we.
Here are some options, ranging from simple adjustments to deeper commitments. Don’t feel like you need to adopt all of these at once. Consider them a menu, not a checklist.
Start Small: Adjust Your Reading
The simplest thing you can do is read your Bible with fresh eyes. When you encounter Old Testament promises to Israel, resist the instinct to automatically spiritualize them or apply them exclusively to the Church. Ask: “What did this mean to the original audience? Does the text give any indication that this promise has been transferred?”
Typically, the answer is no.
Pay attention to the New Testament’s quotations of the Old Testament, especially in the many cases when they come from the Septuagint. Ask what the Greek reveals that you might miss in English. This is, after all, what we do every week here at The LXX Scrolls.
Go Deeper: Study the Jewish Roots of Your Faith
Christianity didn’t emerge from a vacuum. It grew out of Second Temple Judaism. The Passover became the Lord’s Supper. Baptism has roots in Jewish mikveh. The structure of early Christian worship borrowed heavily from synagogue practice.
Understanding these roots doesn’t make you less Christian. It makes you a better one. It helps you see the continuity of God’s plan rather than the artificial rupture that Replacement Theology introduces.
There are excellent resources for this. Read about the Jewish feasts and how each one points to Christ. Study the Tabernacle and Temple and see how every detail foreshadows the Messiah’s work. Learn about first-century Jewish culture so you can understand the Gospels in their original context.
Consider Observing the Sabbath
This one is personal to me, so let me share my own experience. I’ve made a deliberate effort to observe the Jewish Sabbath, which begins Friday evening at sundown and ends at sundown on Saturday evening. Not because I believe Gentile Christians are obligated to keep the Mosaic law (Paul is clear that we’re not), but because I’ve found it to be profoundly enriching as an act of love for our Creator.
There’s something powerful about entering into the rhythm of rest that God established at creation and that Jewish people have faithfully maintained for thousands of years. It connects me to the heritage I’ve been grafted into. It reminds me that the root supports me, not the other way around.
If this interests you, start simply. Light candles on Friday evening. Set aside work. Spend time in Scripture and prayer. If you put on music, make it worship or devotional. If you watch TV or movies with your family, make it something that honors God. You don’t have to follow every rabbinic regulation. Just be intentional about your devotion as you enter into rest.
Support Messianic Jewish Ministry
The Messianic Jewish community operates in a uniquely challenging space. They face skepticism from the mainstream Jewish community (which often views them as Christians in disguise) and sometimes from the mainstream Christian community (which doesn’t always know what to do with Jewish believers who maintain their Jewish identity).
These brothers and sisters need our support. Financially, prayerfully, and relationally. Organizations like One for Israel, Jews for Jesus, Chosen People Ministries, and many smaller Messianic congregations are doing vital work. Consider partnering with them.
Explore the Jewish Feasts and Holidays
I’ll be honest: I haven’t yet started observing the Jewish feasts. It’s on my list, and it’s something I want to incorporate into my spiritual life. The feasts are more than just cultural traditions, they’re prophetic blueprints. Passover points to the crucifixion. First Fruits points to the resurrection. Shavuot (Pentecost) points to the giving of the Spirit. The fall feasts— Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur, Sukkot —many believe point to events still future: the rapture, the Day of Atonement for Israel, and the millennial reign.
Understanding these feasts enriches your grasp of both testaments. And celebrating them— even in a simple way —connects you to the story God has been telling since before Abraham.
Pray for Israel
This is the simplest and perhaps most important step. Paul asked the Roman believers to pray for Israel’s salvation (Romans 10:1). That request hasn’t expired. Pray for the peace of Jerusalem (Psalm 122:6). Pray for the Messianic Jewish community. Pray for Jewish people around the world to encounter their Messiah. Pray for wisdom and restraint in Israel’s political and military decisions. Pray that God’s purposes for His people would be accomplished in His timing.
What Replacement Theology Costs Us
I want to pause before we reach the closing and name something that I think often goes unsaid. Because Replacement Theology doesn’t just hurt Jewish people. It hurts us. It costs the Church something profound, and we should be honest about what we’ve lost.
When we allegorize away God’s promises to Israel, we don’t just misread a few Old Testament passages. We lose the ability to read the Old Testament at all with any confidence. If “land” doesn’t mean land, if “forever” doesn’t mean forever, if “Israel” doesn’t mean Israel, then what do words mean? And how do we know that “salvation” means salvation, or that “eternal life” means eternal life?
Replacement Theology doesn’t just reinterpret Israel’s promises. It introduces a hermeneutic— “theory of interpretation,” or more simply, a way of reading Scripture —that, once applied consistently, dissolves the concrete meaning of every divine promise. If God’s unconditional covenants with Israel can be spiritualized into something else, then the hermeneutical principle you’ve just established permits the same treatment of every promise in the Bible.
Including the ones you’re clinging to.
We also lose the richness of typology. When we sever the Church from Israel’s story, we cut ourselves off from the patterns and shadows that make the New Testament luminous. The Passover lamb becomes “just a metaphor” rather than a type fulfilled in Christ. The Tabernacle becomes ancient architecture rather than a blueprint of redemption. The feasts become cultural artifacts rather than prophetic signposts.
And perhaps most tragically, we lose the witness of God’s faithfulness across time. If God can break His covenant with Israel, then His faithfulness is conditional. It depends on our performance rather than His character. And that’s not the gospel. The gospel is precisely that God keeps His promises even when we fail to keep ours. The gospel is grace. And Israel’s story— ongoing, unbroken, stretching across four thousand years of human failure and divine patience —is the single greatest demonstration of grace in all of history.
When we deny that, we impoverish our own faith.
A God Who Keeps His Promises
We’ve traveled a long road together through these four posts. We started in Mainz in 1096, standing in the shadow of violence that Replacement Theology helped make possible. We traced the theological trajectory from Justin Martyr through Augustine and on to Luther, watching as expansion became replacement, as allegory became systemic, as theology became persecution.
We turned to Scripture and found that the biblical evidence against replacement theology is not a marginal case. It’s overwhelming. Unconditional covenants sealed in blood and sworn by God’s own name. Proof texts that dissolve under contextual scrutiny. Paul’s passionate, sustained, apostolically authoritative argument that God has not— and will not —reject His people. Prophetic promises so numerous and so specific that allegorizing them all requires a hermeneutic that would undermine every promise God has ever made.
And now we’ve arrived at the practical implications: Israel needs her Messiah, not because her covenants are broken, but because they point to Him. The Messianic Jewish community is growing in ways that echo prophetic expectation. Modern Israel is prophetically significant but not politically above reproach. And every Christian can take concrete steps to honor God’s enduring commitment to His chosen people.
But I want to end where I began, which is with the character of God. Because that’s really what this whole series has been about.
Replacement Theology, at its core, is a claim about God’s character. It says that God made promises He didn’t keep. That He swore oaths He later revoked. That He bound Himself to a people and then unbound Himself when they proved unfaithful.
And if that’s true, then every promise in Scripture has an asterisk. Every covenant comes with fine print. Every assurance of God’s faithfulness is provisional, contingent, revocable.
But I don’t believe that. And after four posts of evidence, I hope you don’t either.
I believe in a God who delights in keeping His promises. All of them. To Abraham, to David, to Israel, and to you. I believe that when He says “everlasting,” He means everlasting. When He says “irrevocable,” He means irrevocable. When He ties His covenant to the sun, moon, and stars, He means it will last as long as they do.
I believe that the same faithfulness that has preserved the Jewish people through two millennia of exile, persecution, and attempted annihilation is the same faithfulness that secures your salvation. The God who walked between the pieces of the sacrifice while Abraham slept is the God who holds you in the palm of His hand while you stumble.
He is not a God who makes promises and breaks them. He is not a God who chooses a people and unchoses them. He is not a God who says “forever” and means “for now.”
He is the God who delights— delights —in keeping His word. Even when it takes millennia. Even when the fulfillment looks impossible. Even when the world has given up waiting.
The dry bones are living. The scattered are gathering. The hardening is lifting. The Messiah’s own people are beginning to recognize Him, slowly, one by one, congregation by congregation, twenty-three in 1948 becoming tens of thousands today.
God keeps His promises. That’s the lesson of Israel’s story.
And it’s the foundation of yours.
Think about that. I mean that in all seriousness. Devote some real, deep thought to this topic. It really is that important.
The same God who promised Abraham descendants like the stars and then waited twenty-five years to deliver Isaac, that’s your God.
The same God who promised David a throne forever and then allowed that throne to sit empty for six centuries before the Messiah was born in Bethlehem, that’s your God.
The same God who told Jeremiah the exile would last seventy years and then, seventy years later, stirred the heart of a Persian king to send the Jews home. That’s your God.
He doesn’t operate on your timeline. He operates on His own. And His track record, over four thousand years of covenant history, is perfect.
Not a single promise has failed. Not one.
So when you’re in the valley— when the diagnosis is bad, when the relationship is broken, when the career has crumbled, when you can’t feel His presence and you’re wondering whether He’s forgotten you —look at Israel. Look at a people who spent two thousand years scattered across the globe, persecuted in ways that defy comprehension, and yet survived. But not merely survived. They returned. Returned to their land. Returned to their language. Returned to their identity as a nation among the nations.
If God can do that for Israel after two millennia, He can keep His promises to you through whatever you’re facing tonight.
That is the practical takeaway of everything we’ve discussed in this series. Not just “Replacement Theology is wrong.” Not just “Israel still matters.” But this: the God who will not abandon Israel will not abandon you.
His gifts and calling are irrevocable. For them. And for you.
Trust Him. He keeps His promises.
This concludes our four-part series on replacement theology. If this series has been meaningful to you, I’d love to hear about it in the comments. What surprised you? What challenged you? What are you going to study next?
And if you feel called to dig deeper into the Hebrew roots of our Christian faith— into the Septuagint, the Masoretic Text, and the riches hidden in the relationship between them —that’s what we do here at The LXX Scrolls every week.
If you’ve found this work insightful or helpful, please share it with a friend who loves Scripture as much as you do.
And if you want to go deeper into the Word with a full exploration of the “70 Weeks” of Daniel 9, a deep exploration of biblical idolatry with modern context, and other exclusive content (including an ongoing 8-part series exploring the idiom of a woman in travail as a metaphor for the end times), consider becoming a paid subscriber for just $7/month. Your support keeps the scrolls unrolling.
On the other hand, if this work has blessed you but a paid membership isn’t feasible right now, please consider buying me a coffee as a one-time show of support
And finally, if you’re looking for an incredible new Christian book to lead you on a transformational journey without breaking the bank, I have just the thing!
Enter the Transformational books giveaway! Here you’ll find at least 28 (as of this writing) books promising transformation for the cost of nothing but your email address!
Do remember, of course, that by downloading any book from this giveaway you’ll be giving your consent to receive emails from the author in question.
And if you happen to be reading this without having subscribed to the LXX Scrolls, you’ll also have the opportunity to fix that and get my book, The Septuagint: An Introductory Analysis in either ebook or audio with your subscription.
© 2026 LXX Scrolls. All rights reserved.
Excellent article! God bless you